This classic mystery was first published in 1940. And it's very entertaining, especially if you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes. As the Baker Street Irregulars are. This group is dedicated to the great detective and know every story written about him. So when they learn Metropolis Pictures is planning to make a movie of The Adventures of the Speckled Band and have hired Stephen Worth to write the screenplay, the Irregulars are horrified. As a group, they begin a letter campaign threatening the producer F.X. Weinberg unless he fires Worth.
"...this man Worth, hereinafter to be known as that rat, is the author of many stupid and illogical mystery novels...and has many times expressed in public print his contempt for the exploits of Holmes."
Stephen Worth doesn't have a much better opinion of the Baker Street Irregulars: "These cockeyed pantywaist deductionists. These silly-frilly nancy-pantsy dabblers who think they can write about detectives....they're going to learn something in this picture, and they're not going to like it."
Wanting to get the Holmesians off his back (and unable to fire Worth because of an ironclad contract), Weinberg and his secretary, Maureen, devise a plan to bring five of the most well-known Baker Street Irregulars to Hollywood to oversee the script. But when Worth is murdered at their welcome reception, they all become suspects. Banding together, the Irregulars try to solve this puzzling murder. But they're stumped when every clue and red herring they find seems to point back to one of Sherlock Holmes's famous cases. It can't be a coincidence. But who's behind it all?
Irreverent, engaging, humorous and a little zany, I thoroughly enjoyed this mystery. Boucher creates quite a cast of characters, even including a police sergeant named Watson. I found all the nods to Holmes and Watson lots of fun; though you don't have to be familiar with anything Sherlock Holmes to appreciate this mystery because the Irregulars are more than happy to explain each and every connection. There's a touch of screwball comedy in this one that I wasn't expecting, but found amusing. And while I didn't have a clue whodunnit, I loved watching the police and the Irregulars try their best to solve the crime. And the ending made me smile. ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Happy Reading!
There is a branch of the Baker Street Irregulars here in Houston, and I'd like to attend a meeting, just to see. I've read the Holmes and Watson stories, but it's been a while. This book sounds like fun, and happily my library has a copy!
ReplyDeleteThat would be so fun to actually attend a Baker Street Irregular meeting! Though I doubt I know enough about Sherlock Holmes to fit in with them. :D
DeleteLark, how fun! This book sounds like such a treat to read. I'll definitely have to check it out :)
ReplyDeleteI thought it was a lot of fun. But then I've been really liking these classic mysteries lately. :D
DeleteThis book sounds like so much fun! I'm a big fan of Sherlock Holmes, so I'm adding this to my list. Great review, Lark! :)
ReplyDeleteThere's a lot of humor in this one that totally made me laugh. I hope you get a chance to read it sometime.
DeleteI fell in love with Sherlock Holmes as a teenager and I love him still. Wonderful stories! This sounds like it might be a worthy successor. I must check it out. Thanks for this review.
ReplyDeleteI really liked how the Baker Street Irregulars played off one another and how each had a theory and a story. It was fun.
DeleteOoh. I didn't know about this and now I want to read it.
ReplyDeleteIt's another very fun classic mystery. :D
DeleteI had a feeling Mr. Worth was a goner. lol Don't mess with the myth of Sherlock Holmes. Every reader knows that...lol Sounds like a fun read.
ReplyDeleteAnd don't mess with the Baker Street Irregulars! ;D
DeleteWhile it's not my kind of read, I'm glad you enjoyed it.
ReplyDeleteIt was a fun read. But then I do really enjoy these Golden Age classic mysteries. :D
DeleteSherlock Holmes is timeless, as popular today as he was when Sir Arthur Conan Doyle first created him and this books sounds fun. I like the idea of Holmes fans banding together to solve a crime.
ReplyDeleteHolmes is timeless. I wonder if when Doyle first thought him up he had any idea just how popular he would become. He's such an icon now. Everyone has heard of Sherlock Holmes. :D
DeleteI'm glad you enjoyed this one, it sounds like a fun, classic whodunnit.
ReplyDeleteIt is a very fun whodunnit. :D
Delete1940 eh? That's interesting you found this one. Sounds like a good tribute to Sherlock Holmes.
ReplyDeleteI've been trying to read a classic mystery every month this year (I have a long list of them that have been recently reprinted), and it's been a lot of fun.
DeleteA mystery wrapped up in fun! I think I'd enjoy this one! :)
ReplyDeleteThere's just something about this one that'll make you smile.
DeleteThis one is new to me and sounds like great fun!
ReplyDeleteIt was a lot of fun. If you like reading classic mysteries, I recommend this one!
DeleteI've wondered about this book for decades. I really do love the Sherlock Holmes stories, and this sounds like so much fun!
ReplyDeleteThere are things about this one that are so fun. I think you'd like it.
DeleteOh this sounds fun! Honestly, I'm not the biggest fan of the original Sherlock Holmes stories but I love almost every adaptation I've either or read. I will have to add this to my list.
ReplyDeleteI've only read like two of the original Holmes' stories, so I'm not a huge fan either, but I am a fan of the character of Holmes and Watson, and these kinds of adaptations are a lot of fun to read imo. :D
DeleteI like Holmes very much. Love the movie series too.
ReplyDeleteThey've made a lot of very fun Sherlock Holmes movies! :D
Delete